Domestic Violence and Family Law in NYS

---

Introduction

Domestic violence is a critical issue in family law, especially when it comes to custody and divorce proceedings. In New York State (NYS), the presence of domestic violence significantly affects how courts make decisions related to child custody, visitation rights, division of marital assets, and spousal support. Given the serious nature of domestic violence, New York has established various legal mechanisms to protect victims and ensure that these allegations are properly considered in family law cases.

This analysis will explore the impact of domestic violence on family law in New York, focusing on the legal options available to victims, the effect on custody and divorce outcomes, and the advice commonly offered by legal professionals on handling such situations.

Understanding Domestic Violence in the Context of Family Law

1.1 Defining Domestic Violence

Domestic violence is defined under New York Family Court Act as a range of behaviors used by one partner to gain power and control over another. This can include:

• Physical abuse: Hitting, slapping, pushing, or other forms of bodily harm.
• Emotional or psychological abuse: Intimidation, threats, constant criticism, or isolation.
• Sexual abuse: Any forced or coerced sexual acts.
• Economic abuse: Controlling finances or preventing the victim from working.
• Stalking and harassment: Repeated, unwanted contact or monitoring.

Domestic violence can have far-reaching implications in family law matters, as courts are required to take the safety and well-being of children and victims into account when making custody and divorce-related decisions.

1.2 Legal Recognition in New York State

In New York State, domestic violence is recognized as a serious factor that influences the outcomes of family law cases. The state’s laws, particularly under the Family Court Act and Domestic Relations Law, allow for protective measures like orders of protection and also require that domestic violence be considered when courts make decisions about child custody, visitation, and property division.

2. Seeking Protective Orders in New York State

One of the most immediate legal remedies available to victims of domestic violence in NYS is a protective order, also known as an order of protection. This is a legal order issued by a court to restrict the abuser's ability to contact or harm the victim.

2.1 Types of Protective Orders

In New York, there are several types of protective orders available to victims, depending on the urgency of the situation and the stage of the legal process:

• Temporary Order of Protection: This can be obtained quickly and provides immediate protection to the victim. It can be issued based solely on the victim’s testimony, without the abuser present in court (known as ex party).
• Final Order of Protection: Issued after a court hearing, where both the victim and the abuser have an opportunity to present evidence. This order typically lasts for one to five years, depending on the severity of the abuse and the risk to the victim.

These protective orders can include provisions that require the abuser to:

• Stay away from the victim’s home, workplace, or children’s school.
• Cease all forms of contact, including phone calls, emails, and social media
• communication.
• Move out of the shared home.
• Surrender firearms or other dangerous weapons.
• Attend anger management or counseling programs.

2.2 How to Obtain a Protective Order

Victims of domestic violence in New York can file for an order of protection through either Family Court, Criminal Court, or the Supreme Court (if divorce proceedings are ongoing).

Family Court allows for protective orders in cases involving intimate partners, family members, or anyone who shares a household with the victim.

• Filing a petition: The victim must go to court and file a petition requesting a protective order. The court will review the allegations and determine whether to issue a temporary order of protection until a full hearing can be held.
• Evidence required: The court may require evidence of abuse, such as police reports, medical records, photographs of injuries, or testimony from witnesses. However, even without such documentation, a judge may still grant a temporary order if they find the victim's testimony credible.

The Impact of Domestic Violence on Child Custody

Child custody is one of the most contested issues in family law cases involving domestic violence. In New York, courts make custody decisions based on the best interests of the child standard, and allegations or proof of domestic violence are given significant weight in this analysis.

3.1 Best Interests of the Child Standard

In New York, when determining the best interests of the child, courts consider several factors, including:

• The child’s physical and emotional well-being.
• The stability of each parent’s home environment.
• The child’s relationship with each parent.
• Each parent’s ability to provide for the child’s needs.
• Any history of domestic violence, substance abuse, or mental illness.

Domestic violence, even if not directed at the child, is considered harmful to the child’s well-being. Courts recognize that exposure to violence, even indirectly, can have negative psychological and emotional impacts on children.

4.4 Accelerating Divorce Proceedings

Domestic violence may also accelerate divorce proceedings. When a victim files for divorce on the grounds of domestic violence, the court may prioritize the case to ensure that the victim is protected and can move forward with their life as soon as possible. Protective orders can also be issued during divorce proceedings to safeguard the victim from further abuse.

Legal Strategies and Advice for Victims of Domestic Violence in NYS

Legal professionals that work with victims of domestic violence in family law cases emphasize the importance of taking strategic steps to protect both their personal safety and their legal rights.

Key recommendations include:

5.1 Prioritize Safety First

For victims of domestic violence, the primary concern should always be safety. Legal professionals advise victims to:

• Seek an order of protection: This can provide immediate legal protection from the abuser. Courts in New York take domestic violence seriously and can issue temporary orders quickly.
• Document the abuse: It is important to gather and preserve evidence, such as photographs of injuries, text messages, emails, police reports, and witness statements, which can be used in court.
• Create a safety plan: Victims should work with domestic violence advocacy groups or legal professionals to create a plan for safely leaving the abusive situation, especially if children are involved.

5.2 File for Custody or Divorce Strategically

In cases where domestic violence is a factor, legal professionals may recommend filing for custody or divorce strategically:

• File for custody or sole custody: Victims should request sole custody if the abuser poses a danger to the child. Supervised visitation can be requested to ensure that the child remains safe during any contact with the abusive parent.
• Leverage the protective order in divorce proceedings: Protective orders not only provide physical protection but can also influence divorce negotiations. For example, they may impact spousal support awards, property division, or living arrangements.

5.3 Responding to False Allegations

In some divorce and custody disputes, false allegations of domestic violence may arise, with one party making unfounded claims to gain a legal advantage. Legal professionals recommend that individuals accused of false allegations:

• Gather evidence: Just as victims are advised to document abuse, those falsely accused should gather any evidence that disproves the allegations, such as communications, witness statements, or alibis.
• Seek legal counsel: It is crucial to work with an attorney experienced in family law and domestic violence cases to challenge false allegations and protect their legal rights.